Josh Duggar’s latest motions in child pornography case denied by court: Here’s why



Josh Duggar‘s newest makes an attempt to suppress statements and pictures in his kid pornography case had been unsuccessful and the U.S. District Court docket overseeing his case is explaining why.

On Wednesday, Oct. 13, U.S. District Pass judgement on Timothy L. Brooks filed a lengthy memo to listing the courtroom’s causes for denying 4 motions filed through Duggar’s criminal group again at a listening to on Sept. 27. Duggar’s 4 motions requested the courtroom to suppress statements made through the previous TV famous person to government on Nov. 8, 2019, suppress pictures of his palms and ft taken all the way through his reserving in prison previous this yr, disregard the indictment for violation of the appointments clause, and to disregard for the federal government’s failure to maintain probably exculpatory proof.

“All motions had been denied from the bench following an in-person evidentiary listening to on September 27, 2021. The Court docket has orally defined its causes for denying the motions; the next Order supplies additional rationalization. To the level the rest on this Order differs from what was once said from the bench, this Order will keep watch over,” Brooks’ memo starts.

Brooks explains that after federal brokers arrived at Duggar’s automotive trade again on Nov. 8, 2019, they correctly knowledgeable Duggar he was once unfastened to go away if he needed. The pass judgement on additionally defined that the courtroom discovered brokers to not be at fault for taking Duggar inside of a car to habits an interview. 


“It is usually undisputed that the passenger-side door subsequent to the place Mr. Duggar was once seated remained unlocked all the way through the interview. The Court docket subsequently unearths that Mr. Duggar was once no longer restrained, and this issue weighs within the Executive’s choose,” the submitting states.

Anna Duggar and Josh Duggar pose during the 42nd annual Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) at the Gaylord National Resort Hotel and Convention Center on February 28, 2015 in National Harbor, Maryland. Duggar is now awaiting trial after pleading not guilty to child pornography charges.

Anna Duggar and Josh Duggar pose all the way through the forty second annual Conservative Political Motion Convention (CPAC) on the Gaylord Nationwide Hotel Resort and Conference Heart on February 28, 2015 in Nationwide Harbor, Maryland. Duggar is now anticipating trial after pleading no longer in charge to kid pornography fees.
(Kris Connor/Getty Pictures)

Moreover, the pass judgement on mentioned a recording of Duggar’s dialog with government on Nov. 8, 2019 was once performed ahead of the courtroom within the Sept. 27 listening to. The tone of the interview was once “conversational, no longer heated,” the pass judgement on dominated. 

“Now not most effective did Mr. Duggar signal a kind demonstrating he understood he was once waiving his proper to recommend, however he additionally manifested a transparent working out of the waiver and the voluntariness of his movements through reminding the brokers ahead of wondering started that he ‘won’t solution the entirety,'” courtroom medical doctors proceed.

At one level, then again, the pass judgement on claims the courtroom did to find one remark made through the federal brokers on that day that may be “noticed as a misleading technique.” Nonetheless, “Mr. Duggar didn’t fall for” it, the medical doctors said.


Duggar has additionally taken factor with the images taken of his palms and ft when he self-surrendered to legislation enforcement on April 29, 2021. The pictures had been taken in an internal room as a part of the reserving procedure on the Native land Safety’s Fayetteville, Arkansas place of business.

Whilst being fingerprinted, an agent “spotted a scar on Duggar’s left thumb” and Duggar “consented” to having his palms photographed, which came about to additionally seize his ft. The previous “19 Children and Counting” famous person argued that the federal government wanted a warrant ahead of photographing him and violated his Fourth Modification rights.

“There is not any criminal authority to signify brokers wanted a warrant ahead of they may {photograph} Mr. Duggar’s palms and ft. Mr. Duggar consented to being photographed. Due to this fact, no fourth Modification violation took place,” Brooks dominated.


Some other movement made through Duggar was once to disregard the indictment towards him for the reason that federal brokers who had been concerned within the investigation of his prison fees had been performing below any individual who was once “improperly appointed as Performing Secretary.”

The former star of '19 Kids and Counting' was arrested in Arkansas in April.

The previous famous person of ’19 Children and Counting’ was once arrested in Arkansas in April.
(Washington County Police Division)

Brooks referred to as the movement “frivolous,” including that there’s “no criminal toughen for Mr. Duggar’s declare that an indictment passed down through a correctly impaneled grand jury could be topic to dismissal because of an alleged Appointments Clause violation.”

Finally, Duggar argued that cops most effective imaged his digital units and no longer others’. 

“The Court docket unearths that legislation enforcement’s resolution to not forensically seek and symbol positive digital units was once made pursuant to a good-faith trust that such further investigative steps had been useless,” the pass judgement on dominated in opposition. “Legitimate causes might exist to criticize legislation enforcement’s thoroughness (or lack thereof) on cross-examination, however the Court docket is solely no longer persuaded that legislation enforcement’s movements upward thrust to the extent of a constitutional deprivation of due procedure that will require the dismissal of the indictment towards Mr. Duggar,” the ruling concludes.

Duggar’s pre-trial convention is recently scheduled for Nov. 18.


The disgraced former truth famous person was once arrested through U.S. Marshals on April 29 in Arkansas. At some point later, he was once indicted on federal child pornography charges and pleaded no longer in charge. He was once granted unlock through a federal pass judgement on as he awaits trial.

Duggar starred on TLC’s “19 Children and Counting” till it was once pulled from the community in 2015 following revelations that he had molested 4 of his sisters and a babysitter. His oldsters mentioned he had confessed to the fondling and apologized.

He previously apologized for a pornography addiction and cheating on his wife, Anna. Josh and Anna Duggar had been married since 2008 and proportion six kids with a 7th at the approach.


Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here